Lake Country Area Rummage Sales

Keep CALM and Find some Rummage Sales

Some of my kids’ most-played-with toys are items I have picked up at garage sales! To me, finding a good deal is like winning the mommy jackpot. I thrive on a good morning of rummage shopping and coffee. Plus, most rummage sale finds are new or gently used items.

Spring is upon us, which means it is Rummage time. Whether you are planning to participate in one or if you are making your “rummage wish list” like me, it’s sometimes hard to know when and where to go. That’s why Lake Country Family Fun has created a Rummage Sale Guide. We wanted a central, non-cluttered location for local Rummage Sales especially the bigger church and/or neighborhood rummages.

Please thank your Rummage Sponsor:

Aspire Dance Center

How to list your Rummage Sale in this Guide

We welcome rummage sale additions to this guide, in fact, we encourage it! Please fill out the form at the bottom of this guide with your rummage information. Our focus will be larger rummage sales, not one-house ones. Rummage sale details in italics below mean we are awaiting further information on specifics.

As you read this guide, please be aware that Rummage Sales may change. Please verify sale before attending.

2026 Rummages and Yard Sales

May 2026 Rummage Sales

Estate Sale – Merton/ Hartland
- May 7 through May 9
- 9:00 am to 5:00 pm daily
- This estate sale offers a glimpse into a life filled with love and family. Each piece, from childhood toys and antique telephones, to vintage china sets, old school books, Little Golden classics, generations of vintage clothing, and Norman Rockwell plates, tells a story of a lifetime lived with care. Don’t miss this chance to discover these generational treasures, as well as practical kitchenware and canning supplies, coupled with oodles of holiday collectibles and one-of-a-kind décor.
- Location: W282 N6836 Main St., Merton; near the intersection of Main Street and VV. GPS address: W282N6836 Main Street Sussex 53056

Arrowhead High School Warhawk Interact FREE Book Fair
- May 9
- 8:30 am to 11:00 am
- Arrowhead High School South Campus cafeteria
- All are welcome, and all genres and age groups of FREE books will be available – ready to take home for your summer reading adventures.
- Free snacks will be available, too!

Spring Creek Rummage Sale
- May 9, 2026
- 8:30 am to 1:00 pm
- Held at Spring Creek Church: N35W22000 Capitol Dr, Pewaukee, WI, 53072
  - Enter through Door #1: Student Entrance
- *Please note: this sale is CASH ONLY
  DONATION GUIDELINES
  Our sale only happens because of the kindness of donated items.
  Donations will be accepted Mon May 4 – Wed May 6 from 9AM-8PM.
  Suggested Items: baby clothes sized newborn to 24 months, gently used toys, books, purses, jewelry, housewares, furniture, tools, recreation equipment, linens, decorations, crafting supplies and holiday items.
  Please come to Door #1: Student Entrance to drop off your items.
  Volunteers will be available to help carry items in and carts are available.
  Tax donation receipts will be available.
  Please no clothing larger than 24 months, TVs, car seats, mattresses or exercise equipment.

New Berlin Neighborhood Rummage Sale
- May 14 through May 16
- Thursday May 14th 5:00 pm to 8:00 pm
  Friday May 15th 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
  Saturday May 16th 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
- Rummage Sale on 3 streets; Crestview Dr., Woodland Dr., and Woodshire Dr. New Berlin.
- —
- 14th Annual Rummage Sale. 4 Families downsizing after years of collecting.
- Starts Thursday, May 14 thru Sunday, May 17, 2026. 8am-5pm!!
- On Lincoln Ave., between Moorland and Sunnyslope.
- 100’s come out every year as the hosts have a variety of everything and priced to sell. Re-stocked every year!! Best thing it’s held at one house with 4 households worth of stuff that has a circle driveway full of goodies and a garage full of collectables and more.
- Everything from Hand Tools, Bath, Collectables, Seasonal, Clothes, Toys, Games, Household, Tools, Puzzles, Books, Office Supplies, Knick Knacks, Brewers, Bucks, Packers, Table, Water Table, Sporting Goods, Tennis Balls, Swim Gear, Bath Supplies, Gift Wrap, Pots, Pans, Kitchen, Computer supplies, Boys Clothes, Men’s Clothes, Woman’s Clothes, Shoes, Carrying Bags, Games, Art’s Craft’s, Seasonal – Halloween, Easter, Christmas, St. Patrick’s Day
  Housewares, Home Goods, Kids toys, Disney, Princess, and more!!and sooooo much more……literally 100’s of items.

Mukwonago Rummage Sale
- May 29 through May 31
- 9:00 am to 2:00 pm
- Come hunt for great deals, swap stories and meet awesome local families – all while supporting the amazing KidsCycle community!
- There will be multiple sellers all in one spot, so if you are interested in selling, post in the event.
- All items will be kids or maternity specific and the rummage will follow KidsCycle guidelines.

Multi-Family Rummage Sale — Pewaukee/Waukesha/Delafield
- Saturday May 30
- 9:00 am to 3:00 pm
- Multi-family rummage sale in the New Vision Church Parking Lot
- New Vision Church, N14W27995 Silvernail Road, Pewaukee WI 53072 (Hwy SS & I-94 Interchange)
- Come out to shop, or set up your own tables. Sellers keep their earnings. Sign up at newvisionbic/rummagesale
- A little of everything – household items, holiday, furniture, pet supplies, kids, sports, clothing, womens clothing sizes 12/14/L/XL, books, decorations, games, art, plants
- The New Vision Church sale will accept donations. Proceeds will help raise funds for a supportive housing ministry.
- A neighborhood artisan baker will be giving out bread samples

June 2026 Rummage Sales

Delafield Presbyterian Church Annual Rummage Sale
- June 18 through June 20
- 9:00 am to 4:00 pm each day
- Delafield Presbyterian Church: 1851 N Genesee St, Delafield, WI
- Come and find that special item at reasonable prices

ADD your Rummage or Garage Sale!

Looking for a place to donate your lightly used clothing or items? Try our guide with 14 ideas.