Best Local Fish Fry

/ Around Town, Eats, Guides, On Instagram, Reviews, Spring Time / 11 Comments

When you say Wisconsin, many things come to mind, but one of them is Fish Fry! Did you know some areas of the country don’t even know what a “Fish Fry” is? We are proud to have so many wonderful options for a Friday Fish Friday so close to home. Whether you like your fish baked or fried, or you prefer your potatoes baked, mashed or pancakes, we’ve got a great guide for you!

Our popular Fish Fry guide has connected many readers to great local Fish Fry restaurants! These fish fry restaurants are listed in no particular order [by county]. And don’t forget to vote for your favorite! Last year, Stolley’s Hogg Alley won the title of Best Local Fish Fry in Lake Country, with Joe Mama’s coming in second. Who will win this year?

2018 Voting is now closed. 

Please give a big thank-you to our Fish Fry Guide Premiere Sponsor:

Crawfish Junction

Fish Fry

Welcome to Crawfish Junction!

Located on County Hwy A between Lake Mills and Watertown, in the booming metropolis of Milford. If you want it, we’ve got it! Featuring a rustic, casual atmosphere, awesome drinks, fun people, live entertainment, and some very unique food. Come out for our award winning, out of this world Friday Fish Fry, huge sandwiches, insane burgers, steaks, seafood and prime rib.

It’s preposterously perfected for an unordinary extraordinary experience. Try saying that fast five times!

Tripadvisor Review

Hours
Monday – 11am – Close
Tuesday – Closed
Wednesday & Thursday – 4pm – Close
Friday & Saturday – 11am – Close
Sunday – 10am – 8pm

Kitchen Hours
Monday – 11am-9pm
Tuesday – Closed
Wednesday & Thursday – 4pm-9pm
Friday & Saturday 11am-9pm
Sunday – 11am – 9pm (April thru October)
Sunday – 11am – 8pm (November thru March)

“The restaurant was great about taking reservations and giving us a table with lots of room. Everyone at the table had some kind of fish fry for dinner and we shared alligator. The fish and the sauces were really good. Our waitress was really good. We will be going back – it is a new favorite!” – Val

Website
Facebook
Untappd
Our Menus

Also thank our Fish Fry Guide Title Sponsors:

Bildas
Bass Bay Brewhouse
Wingin’ It
Rustix
Knuckleheads
Stolley’s Hogg Alley

Thank you to our Highlight Sponsors:

Weissburgers, 5 O’clock Club, Kurt’s Steakhouse, Palmyra Cornerstone, Ox & Cats, In Cahoots, Donny’s Girl, Ron’s Cozy Corner, and St. Paul’s Parish

The winner of the 2018 Lake Country Family Fun
Best Local Fish Fry is…

Joe Mama’s Bar and Grill in Colgate!

Runners up:

Stolley’s Hogg Alley
Ron’s Cozy Corner
Rumor’s Sports Bar and Grill
Woody’s Bar and Grill

2017 Winner: Stolley’s Hogg Alley

Fish Fry Guide By County

Eagle

Knucklehead Pub & Grub

*Title Sponsor*

Fish Fry

Address:
100 South St
Eagle, WI 53119

Website: http://knuckleheadpub.com/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/KnuckleheadPub/

Review: “Friday night fish fry is DELICIOUS. Price point is great. Staff is friendly and has a great atmosphere. Awesome gastropub.” – Delaine A

Rustix

*Title Sponsor*

Fish Fry
Address:
105 W Main St
Eagle, WI 53119

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Rustix-359068931211904/

Review: “Got the fish fry and was delish. The applesauce was OUT OF THIS WORLD! The atmosphere was fun and small town-ish. Glad we stopped for sure.” – Erin L

St. Theresa Church
136 W Waukesha Rd
Eagle, WI 53119

Muskego

Bass Bay Brewhaus in Muskego

*Title Sponsor*

Fish Frys

Address:
S79W15851 Aud Mar Dr
Muskego, WI 53150

Website: www.bassbaybrewhouse.com 

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/bassbaybrewhouse/

Review: “Great Fish Fry! Great service! Very family friendly! Best Fish Fry I’ve ever had!” – James D.

Oconomowoc

Stolley’s Hogg Alley

*Title Sponsor*

fish fry

Address:
2008 N. Venice Beach Rd
Oconomowoc, WI 53066

Website: www.stolleyshoggalley.com

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/StolleysHoggAlley/

Review: “Baked fish, german potato salad and potato pancakes!!! So Delicious!!! Great service and atmosphere! We will be going back and recommending to others!” – Andrea A.

Ron’s Cozy Corner

Address:
W359N5920 Brown St
Oconomowoc, WI 53066

Website: www.foodspot.com/ronscozycorner

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ronscozycorner/

Review: “Ron’s fish fry is this best around. Have been to others, but they can’t compare. Great food. Great staff. Thanks Ron.” Donna C

Schwefel’s Restaurant
N58 W39877 State Road 16
Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

The Lakeside Supper Club
37238 Valley Rd
Oconomowoc, WI 53066

Tom and Di’s Rustic Inn
W360N8739 Brown St
Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

Hideaway
N55W34657 Road E
Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

Hops & Leisure
1225 Robruck Drive
Oconomowoc, WI. 53066

Amalias
183 E Wisconsin Ave, Ste 2
Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

Hartland

Seven Seas

fish fry

Address:
1807 Nagawicka Rd
Hartland, WI 53029

Website: http://www.sevenseaswi.com

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/sevenseaswisconsin/

Review: “This delicious fish fry includes so much- Homemade pancakes, French fries, the best potato salad and coleslaw and our favorite rye bread from a local bakery.” – Mr & Mrs. P

Ox & Cats Sports Bar & Grill

Address:
W302 N9510 County Hwy E
Hartland, WI 53029

Website: www.oxandcats.com

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Ox-And-Cats-Sports-Bar-Grill-118667641526174/

Review: “Excellent fish fry tonight at Ox’s and Cat’s.! Baked fish was excellent. Great meal, comes with coleslaw, rye bread and (choice of potato) sour cream chives fries are delicious. AMAZING,great atmosphere,definitely recommend.” -Aleesa B.

Max Meier’s Hartland Inn
110 Cottonwood Ave
Hartland, Wisconsin

The Phoenix
129 Cottonwood Ave
Hartland, Wisconsin

Woody’s
W314N7788 Kilbourne Rd
Hartland, Wisconsin

Pewaukee

5 O’Clock Club

fish fry

Address:
N28 W26658 Peterson Dr.
Pewaukee, WI 53072

Website: http://the5oclockclubpewaukee.com/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/The-5-OClock-Club-224336734246056/

Review: “Fried or baked, variety is great!!  Cod, Perch and Bluegill are among our favorites.  For the past 35 years, we’ve enjoyed the friendly staff and hometown feeling we get at the 5 O’.” – Mark and Cory B

Machine Shed Restaurant
N14 W24145 Tower Pl
Pewaukee, WI 53188

Billy Ho
118 Main Street
Pewaukee, WI 53072

Point Burger Bar
W229 N1400 Westwood Drive
Pewaukee, WI 53186

Delafield

Kurt’s Steakhouse

fish fry

Address:
22 Main Street
Delafield, WI 53018

Website: http://www.kurtssteakhouse.com

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/kurtssteakhouse/

Review: “The food at Kurt’s: Five Stars. No Question. Want a delicious steak meal or fish fry in Lake Country? Go here.” – Ross B.

Delafield Brewhaus
3832 Hillside Dr,
Delafield, WI 53018

Angelina’s Restorante Delafield
621 Milwaukee Street
Delafield, Wisconsin 53018

Waukesha

St. Paul Genesee Depot

Address:
S38w31602 Wern Way
Waukesha, WI 53189

Website: https://stpaulgenesee.net/fish-fry

2018 Dates: Feb 16, Mar 2, Mar 16

Review: “We love the fish.  It is always yummy!” – Laurie E. “We drive from New Berlin to your fish fries because they are the best.” -Teri H. “I wish you had one every Friday.” -Dean C.

Cue Club  
2454 N Grandview Blvd
Waukesha, Wisconsin

Finnagains
711 Morgan Ave
Waukesha, WI 53188

Tally’s Tap
S31W24661 Sunset Dr
Waukesha, WI 53186

Genesee Depot

In-Cahoots

Address:
S43W31325 State Rd 83
Genesee Depot, WI 53189

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/InCahoots2/

Review: “After taking the tour of Ten Chimneys national historic landmark, I wanted to go to the bar and grill where the tour guide told us that legendary actor Alfred Lunt used to drink an occasional beer.” – TripAdvisor Reviewer

Nashotah

Nashotah Clubhouse
N44 W32998 Watertown Plank Road
Nashotah, WI 53058

Hollywood’s Roadhouse
W332N6629 Waukesha C
Nashotah, WI 53058 

North Lake

The North Lake Inn
W315N7707 State Road 83
North Lake, Wisconsin

North Lake Bear Trap
W314 N7770 Hwy 83
North Lake, WI 53064

Wales

Finn’s Bar & Grill
220 W. Summit Ave
Wales, WI 53183 

Sussex

Sussex Inn
N64W23300 Main St
Sussex, Wisconsin 53089 

Okauchee

Golden Mast
W349W349 N5293 Lacy’s Lane
Okauchee, WI 53069

Kickswitch
N51W34950 Wisconsin Ave
Okauchee, WI 53069

Menomonee Falls

Schwabenhof in Menomonee
N56W14750 Silver Spring Dr
Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

The Main Mill
N88W16521 Main St.
Menomonee Falls, Wi

Brookfield

Slim McGinns West
14735 W. Lisbon Road
Brookfield, WI  53005  

Forgot a Fish Fry?

If you are a local fish fry or know of a good one and would like it added to this list, please email us at erin@lakecountryfamilyfun(dot)com with your information. You can also email us via the contact form.
Contact Form