Lake Country Area Rummage Sales

Keep CALM and Find a Rummage Sale

Some of my kids’ most-played-with toys are items I have picked up at garage sales! To me, finding a good deal is like winning the mommy jackpot.  I thrive on a good morning of rummage shopping and coffee.  Plus, most rummage sale finds are new or gently used items.

Spring is upon us, which means it is Rummage time.  Whether you are planning to participate in one or if you are making your “rummage wish list” like me, it’s sometimes hard to know when and where to go. That’s why Lake Country Family Fun has created a Rummage Sale Guide.  We wanted a central, non-cluttered location for local Rummage Sales especially the bigger church and/or neighborhood rummages.

How to list your Rummage Sale in this Guide

We welcome rummage sale additions to this guide, in fact, we encourage it!  Please fill out the form at the bottom of this guide with your rummage information. Our focus will be larger rummage sales, not one-house ones. Rummage sale details in italics below mean we are awaiting further information on specifics.

As you read this guide, please be aware that Rummage Sales may change.  Please verify sale before attending.

September 2017 Rummages

  • Weekend of September 15-17

    Our Contributor, Stephanie Cutler, will be hosting a large rummage sale to raise money for a Lyme treatment for her husband in December. See details below:

    The 8th annual Watertown Fall Citywide Rummage Sale will be held Saturday, September 16, 2017.

  • 3232 N. Interlaken Dr. Oconomowoc will have quality furniture, rugs, framed art, lamps, home accessories, refrigerator, lawn tractor, snowblower, tools, lawn furniture, etc. Everything in great condition! September 15, 16, 17 from 9:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.
  • Oconomowoc Moving Sale/Garage Sale in Thurows Goldenview Estates (424 North Lapham Street)! Thursday, September 14 Friday, September 15 Saturday, September 16 Maybe Sunday. 9:00am-3:00pm daily. Quality household, furniture, garden, sporting goods, books, toys, games, boys & girls clothing & shoes (European, Boden, Joules…), quality men’s & women’s clothing & fall boots!
  • Prairie Creek Subdivision Rummage Sale (Brown Street and Lake Drive (Hwy Z.) Oconomowoc. Friday and Saturday 9 am to 3 pm. Tons of baby and kids stuff; other items as well.
  • Pewaukee Neighborhood Rummage Sale will be September 16 and 17th, 8 am to noon. Timber Ridge Area in Pewaukee. Wide variety of items for sale.
  • SUBDIVISION RUMMAGE in Wales on Thursday, September 14th Friday, September 15th Saturday, September 16th 9:00 am – 5:00 pm. EAST of the Hwy. 83 and Hwy 18 roundabout. Enter south off Hwy 18 @ Oak Crest (Kettle Moraine HS football field) OR south off Hwy 18 @ Pebble Creek. Watch for signs. Some houses may opt to stay open later and/or on Sunday.


  • Weekend of September 22-24

    • Encore weekend of Large “Lyme Bytes” Rummage. Since we had so much donated, we have TONS left to sell. Baby items and gear, toddler clothes and toys, home good galore!!!! Come out and see.  Prices marked down.  One day only SATURDAY SEPTEMBER 23 from 8am to 2pm.  W323S1703 Moraine View Dr Dealfield, WI 53018.  Blue house. Near hwy 83 and hwy 18.  See you there!


  • Weekend of September 28-30


    • Large Households Goods Rumamge sale – W350N5814 FIREFLY CT, Oconomowoc from September 28, 29 and 30 8am to 11am! Wide range of household items: kitchen, bath, decorative and seasonal items, some furnishings, men’s and women’s clothing and accessories. Lawn and garden, pressure washer. Westshore subdivision. (Westview Rd. and Firefly Ct.)
    • Pewaukee Area Historical Society annual Rummage Sale will be held in the STEELE EXHIBIT BLDG on the grounds of the Clark House Museum.  DONATIONS ARE NEEDED – Save your items to be donated until the week before the rummage sale.

      DROP OFF DATES:  September 20, 24 & 27 from 1:00-4:00 p.m., September 23 from 9:00 a.m. – Noon.
      SALE DATES:  September 28th – 4:00-8:00 p.m., September 29th – 9:00 a.m. – 4:00 p.m., September 30th – 9:00 a.m. – Noon
      ITEMS WE CAN ACCEPT:  Knick knacks, specialty linens or bedding, Christmas or holilday decorations, antique & vintage items, crafts, old books, small working kitchen appliances, dishes, kitchen items, home furnishings, artwork, decorative lawn art, small furniture items, vintage clothing, and decorative baskets.
      ITEMS WE CANNOT ACCEPT:  TVs, computers, food, cosmetics, perfume, clothes, large furniture, drapes, electronics, large appliances and exercise equipment.
      ALSO NEEDED:  Newspapers, plastic and paper grocery bags for packaging the purchases.


October 2017 Rummages

  • Weekend of October 13 – 15 OJWC Fall Sale will take place on Friday the 13th from 9am to 6pm and Saturday (half price day) from 8am to 1pm. This is the bi-annual sale held at Dr. Martin Luther church in Oconomowoc. Highly recommend!

November 2017 Rummages

Divine Redeemer Hartland Rummage to benefit the daycare & the youth group. Date set for November 4th the Divine Redeemer gym. More details to come!


ADD your Rummage!

Name of Sale:*
Exact Dates and Times:*
Website Link:
Contact E-mail:
Rummage Contact Phone:
CrossRoads of the Rummage:
Any other information we should know: